Artistic, but hey, what's the problem in that?

9 out of ten.
I liked almost everything about it. It had an fantastic mood to it, it felt like something more than just a flash game. Near-perfect story (for the game) and good voices.
My only real complain is the graphics, sure, the cave and all looks cool. The portraits are nice. But some of the monsters looked a bit strange and bad.

Also, on the fact that you were invincible; you can neither die in Monkey Island, that doesn't make it a bad game. :)